US Datacenter Industry Uses 'Closed-Loop Cooling' Claims and Inflated Job Ads to Mute Local Opposition, Study Finds
Researchers led by Professor Samuel Woolley at the University of Pittsburgh's CTRL reveal how the AI datacenter industry obscures water and power consumption, f
In mid-November 2026, a research team comprising Professor Samuel Woolley and Senior Fellow Dean Jackson of the University of Pittsburgh's Communication Technology Research Lab (CTRL), alongside Maia Woluchem, director of Data & Society's Trustworthy Infrastructures Program, published a study detailing how the AI datacenter industry deploys propaganda, disinformation, and information control to undermine local community opposition.

Image source: https://aiincontext.com/articles/datacenter-industry-uses-propaganda-to-silence-opposition-study-finds
As hyperscale datacenters expand across the United States as the physical backbone of the AI economy, local residents have increasingly pushed back against higher electricity bills, water depletion, noise, and air pollution. The researchers argue that at the very moment critical decisions are being made about facility siting, resource usage, and community obligations, the industry is deliberately shaping the public information environment through mailers, text messages, TV spots, and targeted digital advertising.
Astroturf Campaigns, Dark Money, and Unverified Job Figures
According to the study, tech companies and datacenter developers are backing traditional corporate persuasion with opaque non-profits and "dark money" groups—political and advocacy organizations that do not disclose their donors—to obscure corporate ties.
The report highlights "Elevate New Mexico" as an organization that presented itself as a grassroots local initiative while hiding its connections to corporate datacenter entities, a classic example of astroturfing (creating the illusion of spontaneous public support).
The researchers also scrutinized the industry's headline economic promises. An advertisement by Build American AI—an advocacy group linked to Lead the Future, an industry political action committee (PAC) funded by OpenAI and Andreessen Horowitz—claimed that datacenters created 57,785 jobs in Texas. While precise on the surface, the researchers note that the ad fails to clarify how many of those roles remain permanent after construction finishes, or whether lower-paid subcontractor positions such as cafeteria, landscaping, and custodial staff without benefits are bundled into average wage figures. Similarly, claims of tax revenue windfalls routinely omit the substantial tax exemptions and abatements granted to attract developers, which directly reduce funding available for public schools and local services.
Technical Jargon and Non-Disclosure Agreements Over Water and Power
To deflect mounting environmental scrutiny, developers frequently lean on technical framing that minimizes perceived resource strain. The study examines two prominent industry terms:
- Closed-loop cooling: Systems designed to recirculate water rather than lose it to evaporation still risk shifting substantial water demand up the supply chain to the power plants generating electricity for the facilities.
- Behind-the-meter power: Generating electricity on-site outside the main utility distribution meter does not eliminate grid reliance, as facilities still depend on the public grid for backup and stability while competing with utilities for electrical components.
Beyond framing, the report documents active efforts to withhold operational data. Most datacenters do not report their water usage at all, and non-disclosure agreements (NDAs)—sometimes signed in cooperation with local officials—limit public oversight. In The Dalles, Oregon, Google paid the city's legal fees after local authorities withheld records detailing a datacenter's water consumption; the city eventually agreed to release the records in a settlement with The Oregonian newspaper.
Smearing Local Organizers and Calls for Mandatory Transparency
The researchers warn that opposition rhetoric is escalating into coordinated smears against local organizers, who reported being labeled online as "Antifa," "commies," or "Chinese bots."
These narratives have reached prominent industry figures. In May 2026, investor Kevin O'Leary, who is developing one of the world's largest datacenters, publicly called two activists "proxies for the Chinese government" before later admitting he had "no evidence." While similar claims have circulated among tech executives and Washington policymakers, the authors contend that datacenter proponents themselves are the ones relying on coordinated manipulation tactics, urging officials not to dismiss local community grievances as foreign propaganda.
A notable structural pattern emerges when connecting the report's economic and environmental findings: the industry aggressively publicizes hyper-specific aggregate figures when they favor expansion, such as the 57,785 Texas jobs claim, while simultaneously using NDAs and municipal legal defenses to keep granular resource metrics like water consumption off the public ledger.
To restore accountability, the authors recommend that state and federal policymakers enact mandatory transparency laws requiring datacenters to disclose water and power consumption, permanent job creation, and tax subsidies, alongside stricter disclosure rules for advertising and campaign finance. As a policy recommendation report, however, these measures remain proposals rather than enacted federal mandates, leaving enforcement dependent on future legislative action.
Sources
- AI In Context: The datacenter industry is using propaganda to fight opposition | Samuel Woolley, Dean Jackson and Maia Woluchem
- Source New Mexico (Cited Original Reporting): A secretive ad campaign calls on New Mexicans to support controversial Project Jupiter data center